An article appeared in The Conversation last week about how the food industry gets us to buy and eat ‘nutritionally worthless’ foods and drinks. The thing I found most interesting about the piece was when the authors were talking about number of choices we have today when we take a walk down a supermarket aisle as compared with in the 1960s.
Today, supermarkets stock about 30,000 items. That’s a lot of breakfast cereal or yogurt from which to choose. By comparison, anyone doing a weekly shop in the 1960s had between 600 and 800 items on the shelves.
One of the things we complain about in Australia is that we have limited choice when it comes to diabetes devices and management options. This is true when we compare what is available here with the options of those in the USA and Europe. I have seen and held and played with all sorts of devices that I would love to be able to use, but they are not available on our fair shores – and not likely to be launched here either. ‘Market is too small’ is the reason given all the time.
I like choice and as a consumer advocate, I am the first to say that all the options for management of our diabetes should be before us before we make a decision as to what we will use. It frustrates me that I cannot choose to use a T-Slim pump or the OmniPod system.
I’m not sure exactly how many BGL meters are available in Australia, but I know it’s certainly not as many as at any Walmart I’ve popped into when travelling in the US. I’m always astounded at the ‘diabetes aisle’ in these stores.
Do we want that sort of choice when it comes to diabetes management tools? I’m not sure. I guess I like the idea of being able to choose the device best-suited to me. Do I think that we need a choice of two hundred thousand (slight exaggeration) BGL meters that do pretty much the same thing? Maybe not. I actually do think that we have a good selection here from which to choose and don’t really feel we’re missing out.
But it’s a different matter with pumps. There are not really that many pumps on the market to begin with. We have a choice of only four or five here. We don’t have the option of a tubeless pump, which is definitely a point of difference, nor a touch screen pump.
Some may say we shouldn’t complain – that a pump is an insulin delivery device and as long as it does that, everything else is just fancy-pants add-ons that mean nothing.
But surely that same argument can be applied to everything. We don’t need choice in the cars we drive – a car gets us from point A to B – leather seats and auto windscreen wipers are superfluous. Or a phone is a device to call people and chat – cameras, calculators and other applications are unnecessary and bonus extras.
We wouldn’t accept that. We SHOULDN’T accept that.
For me, when it is time to consider a new pump or CGM or BGL meter, the things that are the most important are safety and accuracy. But I do want to be able to line up all the options, look at their particular features and then make an informed decision. It’s my right to choose.







4 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 11, 2014 at 4:00 pm
Jeann
Good point, Renza,
I am happy with my meter. I am thrilled with my pump but I didn’t have a large choice as you said.
It is a bit sad when a ‘smaller market’ prevents us from accessing items which may make it easier for us.
LikeLike
August 12, 2014 at 2:34 am
ro0301
Just a few thoughts: Perhaps view the many choices of pumps and other equipment available via internet, then, through your USA doc contacts, make arrangements to order, ship, and pay to any of these people. You’d certainly have to iron out the wrinkles involved between you! And there have been available many reviews of technology stuff on various doc’s, done by writers with diabetes themselves. Together with those USA journalists and yourself writing enough about your needs, maybe the D tech companies would offer Australia some goods, too!!
Renza, you may have already exhausted all options. These are, as I wrote, just some ideas. I feel for y’all “down under”!
Love your posts, you keep it real!!
Rose K”
LikeLike
August 12, 2014 at 7:57 am
kevinruess
Sounds frustrating indeed. Still the US has its limitations as well – Europe seems the most ahead of the game by allowing closed loop technology in pumps that go a long way to automatically reduce lows – an important tool in my opinion. As I read about the frustrations with pumps however, it’s comforting to know that very controlled BG can be obtained without a pump and with just injections – often with better results. Nonetheless, having the choice to pump or not is absolutely essential and that should be fought for.
LikeLike
August 15, 2014 at 4:13 pm
misst1db
I’d love to see the ‘Snap’ pump. The ability to add up several item of food rather than just a total of your meal sounds great! But I am guessing it won’t be in Australia anytime soon. However first I would rather see CGMs on Health Insurance schedules here in Oz!!
LikeLike