It’s been a big week. Of advocacy and misconceptions and stigma and messages getting lost.
DessertCalledDiabetesGate was exhausting and the wash up of it for me is really just how disappointed I am in the whole situation.
This post is not about trying to keep the issue alive – especially given that when I wrote about it on Tuesday I was suggesting we all just walk away. In fact, this post isn’t really about the café and the dessert at all.
No, this post is about how we, as a community, dealt with the situation and how, in my opinion, many of us got it wrong. And because we got it wrong, our real message was lost.
While many people asked the café politely to change the name of the dessert and were able to articulate the reasons why, many others got defensive and aggressive. Some attacked the café, others attacked individuals who disagreed with their stance. It got ugly at times – very ugly. Our community went from looking like people genuinely concerned about trying to stop stigma about our health condition to a bunch of wowsers.
And from there, it was a short leap to ‘Australians can’t take a joke anymore’ and ‘it’s political correctness gone mad’. Our community was attacked on Facebook, in the comments sections of news articles and on television. Studio 10 picked up the story and the show’s panel discussed it. Thanks to Jessica Rowe for being the voice of reason on the show who tried see the situation from ‘our’ side.
But that’s where the message got lost. It stopped being about diabetes. Instead, it became about people needing to lighten up and have a laugh. I laugh at myself and MY diabetes all the time. But I don’t do it at the expense of others. I would never make a joke about someone else’s medical condition or someone else’s diabetes.
We need people to understand why it’s not okay to call a dessert diabetes. We need people to understand the hurt and the stigma they are contributing to when they use this ‘humour’. We need people to understand that it’s not that we can’t laugh at ourselves – it’s just that we are a little sick of the misconceptions out there about diabetes.
We can’t get the wider community to understand our side when we get abusive or aggressive or get our messages mixed up. We can’t successful advocate anything if we can’t do it collaboratively, evenly and calmly. This doesn’t mean that we all need to agree – clearly there were some people who couldn’t have cared less about this particular issue – and that’s fine!
United we stand, divided we fall. This week, on this occasion, I believe we fell. Quite spectacularly.
There’s lots coming up in the next few weeks and if you live in Melbourne, you may be interested in these couple of events. These events are all run by Diabetes Australia – Vic. (I’m employed by DA – Vic, but they have not asked me to promote their activities here. I’m doing it simply because the events are great and people should try to get along if they can!)
Smack bang in the middle of National Diabetes Week, Diabetes Australia – Vic is hosting a movie evening where we’ll be showing a film called Sweet 16. It’s free, but bookings are essential. Here are the details.
If you are aged 18 – 25 years and live with type 1 diabetes, check out Connect – In – also coming up in July. It’s a weekend full of information and social activities. Details here – book quickly!
The latest in type 1 diabetes research and technology will be covered at the annual Research Revealed event on 26 July. Book now!
Hope you all have a great weekend. Here’s some Alicia Keys for your Friday and for my New York dreaming and planning.







6 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 4, 2014 at 12:44 pm
Mike Hoskins (@MHoskins2179)
Thanks for this, Renza. It’s evidence as to why we, as a D-Community, will never be able to come together 100% and stand together completely. There’s just no way, because that’s not how the human condition operates. We are divided to some extent, despite our many commonalities. And even if some recognize the need to come together and work as one, when you’re talking millions and millions worldwide who simply can’t agree on some fundamental points, and there’s an incredible amount of pent up frustration and rage out there, it’s a lost cause trying to unite on some issues. If we don’t recognize and embrace this reality, and learn to work through that, we will not succeed in how we need to move forward on important issues.
LikeLike
July 4, 2014 at 2:08 pm
RenzaS
You’re absolutely right, Mike. We don’t have to agree on everything – it would be unrealistic to expect that we do. Thanks for reading and commenting. Happy 4th to you, by the way!
LikeLike
July 4, 2014 at 1:45 pm
mairi-anne
I am sure you will understand if I don’t share. Passion and hot heads fuelled our fire the wrong way at times.
LikeLike
July 4, 2014 at 2:08 pm
RenzaS
Thanks, Mairi-anne.
LikeLike
July 4, 2014 at 5:36 pm
BethC
Hi Renza I totally agree with you as far as the disappointment I felt this week at Type 1 & 2’s alike being so aggressive and rude on that cafe’s page. I could not believe that diabetics could turn on each other that way. That was the saddest part of it all. I was personally told by a guy posting a reply said he hoped we all became extinct and Darwin’s theory of evolution would fix us all. And that we had nothing better to do with our time but to trawl through the social media posts looking for trouble and attention. We have also been bombard with sexually explicit descriptions of where we could stick diabetic “whiners”. One other page not related to this café but mocking diabetes actually posted explicit images on their page. i myself did not see this. I just didn’t want to upset myself any further.
One thing that may be of interest to all is that when the Studio 10 program aired a piece on this issue on Tuesday morning 2 mums decided to put in formal complaints to the advertising standards board and Channel 10 were told in no uncertain terms that their behaviour was not acceptable and they had to remove all negative material from their page etc..
I have read their response to the T1D mums and it is very thorough and showed just what they had breeched.
We can only try and educate people and realise that not every one will agree with us that is definitely human nature. The world would indeed be very beige if everyone just went through life like sheep. But to stoop so low as the supporters of the café did was a blight on Australian society showing the pure lack of empathy towards their fellow man. Not that we are sooks, whiners or political correctness advocates.
LikeLike
July 4, 2014 at 11:49 pm
sharon warren
Hi..some good points in your article but I was one of the people posting on the cafe dessert topic on their fb page. I believe people became confused about what they were reading because the page was was being trolled by an american group who have started a hate page called ‘I hate diabetics’. I personally saw their page and they were the ones writing many of the hateful comments on the cafe facebook page. I made the comment to one of them that their hate page violated American disabilty rights and they could be sued. I also pointed out that Australian people with diabetes were afforded protection from their hateful comments by the human rights commission. These comments were directed to the hate group trolls NOT the cafe itself…I disagree that the community ‘fell’…we don’t need to appease the trolls that were writing on this page. The problem was that all the comments were deleted before people could follow them properly…these were not everyday , normal people..they were American, gun toting, extreme , chauvanistic stirrers who had revolting pages of their own. Just wanted to point that out…
LikeLike