The New Year is but a week old, yet Twitter outrage is already in full force.
Jamie Oliver released a photo the other day. There was the cheeky lad standing in front of a giant Coke can, holding up sixteen sachets of sugar. It took me a moment to see why this photo was flooding my social media streams.
But there it was: in the familiar Coca Cola font, across the giant can, the word ‘diabetes’.
And my heart sank.
There it was: unsophisticated messaging at its worse, that we’ve all seen it before. It’s unimaginative and, quite frankly, boring.
No. The reason was because I could taste the stigma, and I could taste the outrage. I could see what was happening and I could see that the outcome would be. Without reading them, I knew the words. I could feel the anger.
I’d seen it all before. Countless, countless times.
Jamie’s response was swift. He apologised on Twitter and removed the photo. That was the right thing to do after doing something thoughtless.
I love Jamie Oliver – I always have. I think the work he does supporting better nutritional choices for kids at school and people everywhere is really important. His profile allows for great reach and he usually is spot on with what he says.
His messaging is generic – it needs to be to reach the masses – but one of the things that I admire is that he doesn’t overstep the mark like some other celebrities. I can’t recall him ever making health claims, other than urging people to eat as much fresh food as they can and encouraging people to cook at home. ‘Teach your kids to cook,’ he says. That’s good advice!
But here he missed the mark here – drinking too much Coke doesn’t cause diabetes. But comments like his do cause stigma to those living with diabetes. How many times have we seen that happen?
I wasn’t all that angry about it this time.
Maybe my response is clouded by the fact that I am currently in the middle of an enormously enjoyable holiday where the most stressful thing I’ve encountered each day is deciding which hat to wear to face the cold. Perhaps I am too relaxed and chilled out and basking in the glow of doing nothing but spending time with my husband, daughter and some wonderful friends. Perhaps it was his swift apology.
In my incredibly fortunate position of enjoying said holiday, maybe it’s easy for me to just dismiss this. It’s easy to not let it add to stresses and pressures of work and life. It’s actually quite liberating! Perhaps something to try more of when reality returns at the end of the month and I go back to work and back to ‘real life.’ Life can be stressful enough without adding social media outrage to the list!
8 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 9, 2015 at 5:52 am
Alanna
THANK YOU for saying what I was trying to get out in such an eloquent way. Enjoy the shit out of your holidays, sorry it’s so damn cold.
LikeLike
January 9, 2015 at 5:58 am
RenzaS
Thanks for your comment, Alanna. I am absolutely enjoying the shit out of our holiday. And we got some snow, so the cold is all worth it. (She says knowing that at the end of the month she will return to Summer and thaw out!)
LikeLike
January 9, 2015 at 7:02 am
StephenS
I’m a Jamie Oliver fan too, and I was saddened, more than anything, when I saw that tweet. So glad he apologized, and hopefully, he can move on from here a more knowledgeable person and a better advocate for all of us.
LikeLike
January 9, 2015 at 7:28 am
Catherine Forbes (@CoastCath)
Beautifully said Renza. Jamie obviously had a very rare brain snap. He apologised. I’m sure he learned a valuable lesson. Now, let’s move on.
LikeLike
January 9, 2015 at 8:10 am
swis12
This is shared very well Renza. I was late to the show and didn’t know about the coke/diabetes picture until Meri shared a blog post. And I admit I did share her post and urge others to tweet to Jamie. FIRST I did search his twitter stream for anything regarding it. I didn’t find anything – not a word. Alanna – the dear soul did enlighten me and share his apology with me on FB but still I don’t think he really did the diabetes community right. His apology (at least the one Alanna sent me) was in response to just one person. It wasn’t something he put out there. You are correct -many celebrities and others often have good intentions but end up selling something in the end and Jamie has not. His motives are pure and simple – make people healthier. He is trusted by everyone who knows who he is. He has done amazing work and has built a name for himself as someone who knows healthy living in regards to food. That is where my ‘outrage’ (although I wouldn’t say I’m outraged – Im disappointed and sad and annoyed but not really outraged) comes in. Because he is so well respected and followed by people who understand healthy eating isn’t a specific diet, or fad or the next miracle solution what he says is taken as truth. I believe sugar is bad. I’m not suggesting I don’t indulge or that I don’t allow my 3 kids with diabetes to indulge, but we know it’s bad so we don’t eat it in excess or even daily. Obviously we know sugar didn’t cause my kids diabetes and we know Type 2 diabetes can’t be defined by too much sugar or even obesity but the world at large doesn’t.
If you were to sit with my 15 year old daughter and listen to how kids at her school misunderstand diabetes and how she feels judged and angry and wants to hide her diabetes because of it – you would see the pain in her when she recounts a story of a kid in her science class telling the teacher she (the teacher) would get diabetes if she didn’t share the cake a student brought her (the teacher). He just wanted the teacher to share the cake but and so he connected indulging in cake/sugar with developing diabetes.
It is a common misconception – one that I even believed prior to our first child being dxd at age 2 in 2007. I don’t blame people for their ignorance about diabetes. I do hold people (people who make a living from knowing nutrition and health) like Jamie accountable for adding to, allow for, encouraging ignorance. Again not outraged but disappointed and hoping that he will say/do more than delete a ‘generic’ photo and provide a more generic apology. Often it is generic photos that perpetuate the ignorance.
Again I appreciate your post and your thoughts and for you as an adult it may be slightly easier to shrug it off but I have 3 kids under 16 who hear the sugar/fat remarks, see the ‘reverse your diabetes now’ ads, and do often feel the judgment of so many who just see generic pictures and think they understand. I didn’t read your ‘about me’ tab so I don’t know if you grew up with diabetes. I don’t have diabetes so I can’t speak personally about it but I did have acne, was short for my age, kicked my heels out when I walked, wasn’t a very good speller, couldn’t conjugate Spanish verbs for shit, didn’t have money for the latest fashions, and was or believed I was pudgy – my teen years were hellish in my head and that was all normal crap. I can’t imagine how much more difficult adding diabetes is for kids who just want to feel normal.
sorry for the long comment.
Tina
LikeLike
January 9, 2015 at 10:08 am
Colleen
Nicely said. I don’t tweet so didn’t know there was a “sort of” apology.
LikeLike
January 9, 2015 at 3:19 pm
skchrisman
I did follow the feed, and also felt “meh” about it. He does more good than harm, so one little faux pas is not going to mar my overall impression of Jamie Oliver. Perhaps we all needed this to happen in order for him to learn the effect it has on us, and join in educating others to give it up already. Not sure you can really get it, unless your life is touched by a T1D or T2D.
LikeLike
January 31, 2015 at 4:55 am
Adam
I thanked him for ‘apologizing’, but couldn’t resist giving him a small stab regarding his love and promotion of pasta, and his apparent lack of information regarding glycemic indexing.
LikeLike